Appraisal Results

Welcome to the Mid Calder Camera Club Appraisal Results Page

Any omissions or discrepancies please contact our Appraisal Officer –


Appraisal 1 – Appraisal 1
Judge – Ron Bell LRPS

October 12th, 2016

PRINTS
BEGINNER
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
David C. 148 19 20 39
Shiela C. 151 15 17 32
INTERMEDIATE
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Grace E. 098 16 15 31
Janet D. 127 13 14 27
Chris D. 128 14 15 29
Richard M. 129 14 18 32
Val R. 130 14 15 29
Martin C. 141 18 19 37
Andrew M. 143 15 16 31
Peter M. 146 17 17 34
Peter B. 152 15 16 31
ADVANCED
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Gordon S. 001 20 18 38
Jim R. 013 17 16 33
Grant C. 025 14 16 30
Margaret L. 052 19 19 38
Sam H. 079 18 18 36
Roy P. 113 20 17 37
Petra M. 118 16 15 31
Gary W. 135 16 16 32
Alistair T 145 16 15 31
PROJECTED
BEGINNER
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
David C. 148 20 18 38
Shiela C. 151 17 19 36
INTERMEDIATE
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Grace E. 098 15 16 31
Janet D. 127 12 12 24
Chris D. 128 14 13 27
Richard M. 129 19 18 37
Val R. 130 14 13 27
Martin C. 141 20 16 36
Andrew M. 143 17 18 35
Peter M. 146 12 13 25
Peter B. 152 17 18 35
ADVANCED
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Gordon S. 001 17 17 34
Jim R. 013 15 18 33
Dougie C. 014 16 18 34
Grant C. 025 15 16 31
Margaret L. 052 16 15 31
Sam H. 079 16 19 35
Roy P. 113 18 14 32
Petra M. 118 17 16 33
Gary W. 135 19 17 36
Alistair T 145 14 18 32

Appraisal 2 – Appraisal 2
Judge – Charles Summers

November 23rd, 2016

PRINTS
BEGINNER
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
David C. 148 19 16 35
Yvonne K. 149 13 18 31
Sheila C. 151 17 15 32
INTERMEDIATE
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Joyce K. 062 16 16
Grace E. 098 15 15 30
Richard M. 129 18 15 33
Val R. 130 17 13 30
Andrew M. 143 15 16 31
Peter M. 146 15 13 28
Peter B. 152 15 15 30
Margaret C. 154 15 15
Iain C. 156 19 18 37
ADVANCED
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Gordon S. 001 15 17 32
Steve C. 002 15 14 29
Jim R. 013 16 16 32
Grant C. 025 16 16
Margaret L. 052 19 18 37
Sam H. 079 16 18 34
Roy P. 113 17 15 32
Petra M. 118 15 17 32
Gary W. 135 18 15 33
Alistair T. 145 15 14 29
PROJECTED
BEGINNER
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
David C. 148 18 17 35
Yvonne K. 149 13 14 27
Sheila C. 151 15 15 30
Jacqui T. 153 15 16 31
INTERMEDIATE
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Joyce K. 062 14 14 28
Grace E. 098 15 14 29
Richard M. 129 17 16 33
Val R. 130 14 14 28
Martin C. 141 18 15 33
Andrew M. 143 13 13 26
Peter M. 146 15 13 28
Peter B. 152 14 16 30
Margaret C. 154 15 15 30
Iain C. 156 15 16 31
ADVANCED
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Gordon S. 001 16 15 31
Steve C. 002 16 14 30
Jim R. 013 16 16 32
Dougie C. 014 14 15 29
Grant C. 025 14 14 28
George R. 033 15 17 32
Margaret L. 052 19 18 37
Sam H. 079 16 16 32
Roy P. 113 18 14 32
Petra M. 118 17 16 33
Gary W. 135 17 17 34
Alistair T. 145 14 15 29

Appraisal 3 – Appraisal 3
Judge – Doug Berndt ARPS

February 15th, 2017

PRINTS
BEGINNER
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Sheila C. 151 17 15 32
Yvonne K. 149 16 15 31
INTERMEDIATE
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Joyce K. 062 13 16 29
Grace E. 098 14 15 29
Richard M. 129 19 18 37
Andrew M. 143 13 14 27
Peter M. 146 14 14 28
Peter B. 152 15 16 31
Iain C. 156 17 17 34
ADVANCED
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Gordon S. 001 19 15 34
Jim R. 013 17 15 32
Sam H. 079 18 16 34
Roy P. 113 14 20 34
Alistair T. 145 14 15 29
PROJECTED
BEGINNER
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Yvonne K. 149 14 13 27
Sheila C. 151 16 15 31
INTERMEDIATE
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Joyce K. 062 14 11 25
Grace E. 098 14 15 29
Richard M. 129 14 13 27
Andrew M. 143 15 16 31
Peter M. 146 15 12 27
Peter B. 152 18 16 34
Margaret C. 154 16 15 31
Iain C. 156 15 16 31
Matt B. 160 16 17 33
ADVANCED
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Gordon S. 001 17 17 34
Steve C. 002 15 16 31
Jim R. 013 17 16 33
Dougie C. 014 17 19 36
Grant C. 025 14 15 29
George R. 033 15 15 30
Sam H. 079 15 15 30
Roy P. 113 14 18 32
Gary W. 135 17 15 32
Alistair T. 145 17 16 33

Appraisal 4 – Appraisal 4
Judge – Nancy MacArthur

April 19th, 2017

PRINTS        
BEGINNER        
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Sheila C. 151 19 20 39
INTERMEDIATE        
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Richard M. 129 16 19 35
Andrew M. 143 17 20 37
Peter M. 146 15 16 31
Peter B. 152 15 16 31
Iain C. 156 14 15 29
ADVANCED        
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Gordon S. 001 19 20 39
Jim R. 013 16 16 32
Roy P. 113 15 18 33
Alistair T. 145 14 17 31
PROJECTED        
BEGINNER        
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Sheila C. 151 20 19 39
INTERMEDIATE        
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Richard M. 129 17 17 34
Andrew M. 143 13 12 25
Peter M. 146 19 11 30
Peter B. 152 17 18 35
Iain C. 156 12 12 24
Matt B. 160 20 15 35
ADVANCED        
Name Club No. Image 1 Image 2 Total
Gordon S. 001 13 12 25
Jim R. 013 19 13 32
Dougie C. 014 12 15 27
Sam H. 079 18 20 38
Roy P. 113 14 14 28
Gary W. 135 14 12 26
Alistair T. 145 18 13 31