IMAGE APPRAISAL and COMPETITION RESULTS
 
   















 

Mid Calder Camera Club runs four regular Appraisals for prints and for projected images, as well as a Portfolio, Equaliser and an Image of the Year (print and projected for Beginner, Intermediate and Advanced) Competitions.

We also participate in Inter Club Competitions, through out the reigon.

This year we have two open appraisals and two themed appraisals. The subjects for the themed appraisals are "Landscapes" and "People".

Open Appraisal 1 Oct 28th (Hand in all images on Oct 7st) Charlie Summers
Themed Appraisal 2 (Landscapes) Nov 25th (Hand in Nov 4th) Ken Roberts
Open Appraisal 3 Feb 24th (Hand in - on or before Feb 3rd) Gerry Tomkinson
Themed Appraisal 4 (People) Mar 24th (Hand in Mar 3rd) Richard Bingham

 

The results for the year 2009 - 2010

The 2010 winners (so far) are -

Overall Submitted Images for Appraisals

Advanced 1st Place
Willie Mills for Prints, and Willie Mills for Projected Images.

Intermediate 1st Place
A 2 way tie for 1st place for Prints between Louise Greenhorn and Craig Townsend,
and Louise Greenhorn for Projected Images.

Beginner 1st Place
George Rosie for Prints, and George Rosie for Projected Images

For the totals - click here.

Upcoming Competitions

Image of the Year Competition 2009 - 2010

Advanced Section - Willie Mills

Intermediate Section - Louise Greenhorn

Beginners Section - George Rosie


Equaliser Competition 2009 - 2010

Willie Mills


Portfolio Competition 2009 - 2010

Ian Mc Intosh


We have also won the following Interclub Competitions this year -

Mid Calder Camera Club vs Midlothian Camera Club
Mid Calder Camera Club vs Livingston Camera Club
 The West Lothian Competition

 

 

Open Appraisal 1 Oct 15th by Charlie Summers

MEMBER
 PRINTED IMAGE TITLE
SCORE
 PROJECTED IMAGE TITLE
SCORE
Gordon Scott (A)
 Dreaming of...A New
Pair of Shoes
20
 My House
13
Pedal Power
18
 Red Balloon
20
Trio
18
 Trapped
16
Steve Collier  (A)
 Bumble Bee Foraging on Rose Bay Willow Herb
14
 Moss and Lichen
15
 
Rope on a Boat
16
Ian McIntosh (A)
 Autumn Fruits
15
 Ant on Bramble Blossum
16
Emmy
16
 Cinnibar Moths
16
Ribbit Ribbit
16
 Three's A Crowd
18
Ian Gidney  (I)
 Mull of Galloway
14
    
Three in a Row
15
    
Tranquil Loch Moidart
14
    
George O'Toole (A)
 Eagles Eye
16
 Falkirk Wheel
17
Musee de l'Armee, Paris
14
 Paris waterway
15
Orchids
15
 Princes Street
15
Fred Roe (I)
        
Vera Roe (B)
        
Willie Mills (A)
 Charlie
17
 Forest Floor Colours
18
J'Adore La Vue
18
 Gottcha
18
Precious Metals
18
 Green Malachite Butterfly
19
Debra Mills (I)
 Lady in Red
19
 Biggar Bonfire
14
 
Tower of Flower
17
 
 
Stephen Williams (B)
        
Stuart Robertson (A)
 Busy Bee
14
 Crocosmia
16
I'm Knackerred
14
 Homing In
16
Steaming Through
15
 On the Charge
17
Jim Reid (I)
 Boats at Murieston Water
16
 End of Autumn
17
Kirsty
18
 Larry's Lily
15
Pink Guitar
16
 Pipers
15
Dougie Cockburn (I)
  
Cauther Sun
14
      Fangs
14
 
Murcia Alley Way 
14
Mike Stone (B)
      
Sarah Jane Keeley (I)
  
   
Linda Richardson (I)
 Little Row Boats
17
 Beasties on a Thistle
15
Sun Dappled Leaves
16
 English Bee
14
Waiting for the Tide
16
 Gorse or Broom
14
Hugh Griffin  (A)
 Beady Eye
16
 Jimmy Cricket
17
Eagle has Landed
17
 Ready for Take Off
16
I'm Watching You
19
 Watching
15
Scott Boyd (I)
  
   
Jim McKenna (I)
 Christmas Cactus Bloom
14
    
  Falkirk Wheel
15
    
  Tulips
15
    
Grant Collier  (I)
     Bridge
16
    Drama
17
    Steps
17
Graham Gilmore (A)
     Aberdour Daffodils
18
    Crichton Castle Walls
16
Steven Dowds (I)
        
Andy Bremner (B)
        
George Rosie (B)
     Fire in the Sky
17
    Made in Scotland
13
    On the Prowl
15
Sandy Ramsay (I) Blair
15
 Crail Harbour
14
  Crail
15
 Dahlia
17
  Don't Look Back
14
 Orchid
18
Tom Anthony (B)
     Academy Sunset
17
    Clearwater
18
    Swan
19
Robert Speirs (A)
 Fast Running Water
15
 Cork screw
14
    Night Light
16
    Pale Face
17
Bob Kelly (B)
     Loch Morlich
15
    MV Sir Walter Scott
15
    Sunrise
15
Louise Greenhorn (I)
 Crammond Causeway
16
 Chestnut
15
Moment of Suspension
14
 Fountain
16
Tantrum
14
 Maned Wolf
16
Paul Hunter (I)
        
Robin Saunders (B)
        
June Fotheringham (I)
        
Lesley Dignon  (B)
        
Steven Bell (B)
        
Liz Robertson (B)
        
Craig Townsend (I) Hope
15
    
  Orchids
14
    
  Waiting for the Angels
15
    


Landscape, Appraisal 2 Nov 25th by Ken Roberts

MEMBER
 PRINTED IMAGE TITLE
SCORE
 PROJECTED IMAGE TITLE
SCORE
Gordon Scott (A)
 Dark Mountain
16
 Blue and Yellow
19
Frosty Morning
20
 The Rock
14
Rannoch Reflections
18
 Snowy River
14
Steve Collier  (A)
  
Two Tree's
15
 
French Field
17
Ian McIntosh (A)
  
 
Ian Gidney  (I)
  
 
George O'Toole (A)
 Sunset at The Vue
19
 Industrial Landscape
18
Castle Keep
16
 Linlithgow Palace at Night
17
Snow Storm Approaching
16
 Salisbury Craggs Edinburgh
16
Fred Roe (I)
  
 
Vera Roe (B)
  
 
Willie Mills (A)
 A Winter's Day, BEM IR
19
 Forth Rail Bridge IR
19
Approaching Storm over Black Rock
18
 Forth Road Bridge IR
18
Dawn Beckoning over Forth Rail Bridge
20
 Road to Glen Etive
18
Debra Mills (I)
 Water Lily at Dusk
20
 Afterglow
16
Stephen Williams (B)
  
 
Stuart Robertson (A)
  
 
Jim Reid (I)
 Boats on Ullswater
18
 A Tree
14
Early Evening Ullswater
18
 Along a Pentland Stream
16
10th Hole at Pumpherston
15
 In sight of the 19th
17
Dougie Cockburn (I)
 Tree in Rapeseed
18
 Another Bridge Shot
16
  Harburn Boating Pond
17
 Glencorse Reservoir
16
 
Rapeseed in Mono
17
Mike Stone (B)
  
 
Sarah Jane Keeley (I)
  
 
Linda Richardson (I)
 Cottage on the Hillside
17
 Faskally Woods
15
Winter Trees
18
 Linlithgow Loch at Sunset
14
Carpet of Flowers
18
 Umbrella of Trees
17
Hugh Griffin  (A)
 Airds Bay
16
 Achnasmeorach
18
Eilean Donan
19
 Autumn in Argyll
20
Glen Ogle
17
 Run Aground
17
Scott Boyd (I)
  
 
Jim McKenna (I)
  
 
Grant Collier (I)  
Windhoek Mountains
19
   
Forth
17
   
Calanaish
19
Graham Gilmore (A)
  
 
Steven Dowds (I)
  
 
Andy Bremner (B)
  
 
George Rosie (B)
 Night time on Bute
20
 Pebbles High Street
20
Break Through
17
 Rising Mist
19
Big Bucc Etive More
20
 Tranquil Sunset
18
Sandy Ramsay (I) Kyle of Durness
15
 Edinburgh
14
  Ready to Go
18
 Morton Reservoir
17
  Sango Bay
19
 Sandy Beach
16
Tom Anthony (B)
 Reflection
18
 Angel in the Clouds
18
Pentland View
17
 Culzean Castle
20
Perthshire Autumn
20
  
Robert Speirs (A)
  
Wood
17
 
Woody Hill Side
20
 
Glencourse Reservior
15
Bob Kelly (B)
 Canal Basin
14
 Canal Sunrise
16
Achallader
17
 Glen Lyon
16
Balquidder
19
 Whitadder River
15
Louise Greenhorn (I)
 Balerno Sunset
15
 Birdsview
20
Sunset on the Forth
20
 Sun Rays Drumbrae
16
View from the Ben
17
 Snowscape
20
Paul Hunter (I)
  
 
Robin Saunders (B)
  
 
June Fotheringham (I)
  
 
Lesley Dignon  (B)
  
 
Steven Bell (B)
  
 
Liz Robertson (B)
  
 
Craig Townsend (I) Loch an Eilean
19
 Low Tide
17
  After Glow
18
 Across the Pyrenees
13
Misty Morn
20
 Loch Garten
17
Derek Mc  
Winter Tracks
18
   
Linlithgow Sky
18
   
Dunbar Beach
18


Open Appraisal 3 Feb 24th by Gerry Tomkinson

MEMBER
 PRINTED IMAGE TITLE
SCORE
 PROJECTED IMAGE TITLE
SCORE
Gordon Scott (A)
 The Chase
17
 The Audience
17
Five Star Knight
14
 The Look
16
Winter Reflections
19
 The Sergeant
14
Steve Collier  (A)
  
   
 
   
Ian McIntosh (A)
  
 
Ian Gidney  (I)
  
 
George O'Toole (A)
        
       
       
Fred Roe (I)
  
 
Vera Roe (B)
  
 
Willie Mills (A)
 Beaming out from the BBC
20
 Arch Over the Clyde
17
Cloverlly(IR Panorama)
18
 Great Blue Herron
20
Striking a Pose
16
 Kirei (beautiful) Flower
16
Debra Mills (I)
  
Forest Floor Variety
15
Stephen Williams (B)
  
 
Stuart Robertson (A)
  
 
Jim Reid (I)
 Rainbow's End
15
 Night Time Reflection
16
Yellow
16
 Pink Guitar
18
Ullswater
14
 Roman Nosey
15
Dougie Cockburn (I)
 View from the Cat
14
    
  Armadillo at Night
17
    
 
   
Mike Stone (B)
  
 
Sarah Jane Keeley (I)
  
 
Linda Richardson (I)
        
       
       
Hugh Griffin  (A)
 House on the Hill
15
 Members Garden
15
Fungii
14
 Raging Torrent
15
Beauford
17
 Cyril
18
Scott Boyd (I)
  
 
Jim McKenna (I)
  
 
Grant Collier (I)  
   
   
   
   
   
Graham Gilmore (A)
  
 
Steven Dowds (I)
  
 
Andy Bremner (B)
  
 
George Rosie (B)
 Glasgow Waterfront
19
 A new day
17
Dynamic Earth
16
 Glasgow STV
19
Sleepy Bathgate
18
 Out of the blue
17
Sandy Ramsay (I) Don't Jump
15
 Feed Me
14
  Waterfall in the Botanics
13
 Orchid
15
  Orchid
14
 Squinty Bridge
16
Tom Anthony (B)
 Snowy Misty New Years Eve
17
 Culzean Castle
16
Evening Armadillo
18
 Linlithgow Palace
17
Cold Feet
15
 Peebles Bridge
15
Robert Speirs (A)
  
Monochrome Fishing
16
 
Nikki
15
 
Sunset Over StAndrews_Bay
14
Bob Kelly (B)
 Crail from the North
15
 3 Boats and a Seal
16
Old Slipway
15
 St Pauls Bay Malta
14
Cobble Patterns
14
 Cloudy Day on the Loch
15
Louise Greenhorn (I)
 Stormy Causeway
20
 Shadows
16
Frozen in Flight
19
 Ghost Horse
17
Affection
16
 Curvature
18
Paul Hunter (I)
  
 
Robin Saunders (B)
  
 
June Fotheringham (I)
  
Just Buzzing About
16
      Nature Walk
14
      Winter Wonderland
17
Lesley Dignon  (B)
  
 
Steven Bell (B)
  
 
Liz Robertson (B)
  
 
Craig Townsend (I) Stag in Water
16
 Dried Blue Yonder
14
  Woodland
13
 Hope Standing
19
Fire's Above and Below
15
 When You Go Home
15
Derek Chambers (B)  
 
Rachel Levy (B)  
Gossiping Women
15
      Loch Ness Splash
14
   
 


 

People Appraisal 4 March 24th by Dr Richard Bingham

MEMBER
 PRINTED IMAGE TITLE
SCORE
 PROJECTED IMAGE TITLE
SCORE
Gordon Scott (A)
 Weaver Man
16
 Rock_Chick
14
If Looks Could Kill
20
 Man in a Turban
16
Gasping for Breath
13
 Alabaster Man
17
Steve Collier  (A)
  
   
 
   
Ian McIntosh (A)
  
 
Ian Gidney  (I)
  
 
George O'Toole (A)
        
       
       
Fred Roe (I)
  
 
Vera Roe (B)
  
 
Willie Mills (A)
 Scary
17
 Gerry Goldwyre Master Chef
17
Portrait Study High Key
14
 Hay There Charlie
16
Portrait Study Low Key
19
 Different Strokes
19
Debra Mills (I)
  
 
Stephen Williams (B)
  
 
Stuart Robertson (A)
  
It’s a Topper
15
      Firing Squad
15
      Sacred Tea
Jim Reid (I)
 Charlie
14
 Cool Kid
15
Daydreaming
15
 Yvonne
17
    Concentration
14
Dougie Cockburn (I)
     Keeper of the Rhythm 16
      The Drummer 14
 
Wull 17
Mike Stone (B)
  
 
Sarah Jane Keeley (I)
  
 
Linda Richardson (I)
        
       
       
Hugh Griffin  (A)
 The Battle's Won
15
 Concentration
15
Independence
18
 Ready for Battle
14
Spring Bubbles
14
 Whats the Joke
14
Scott Boyd (I)
  
 
Jim McKenna (I)
  
 
Grant Collier (I)  
   
   
   
   
   
Graham Gilmore (A)
  
 
Steven Dowds (I)
  
 
Andy Bremner (B)
  
 
George Rosie (B)
 Nearly There
16
 Walking the Ridge
17
Big Drummer
18
 Triumphant
19
Base Player
19
 Artist at work
14
Sandy Ramsay (I)        
         
         
Tom Anthony (B)
 Rest Awhile
15
 Oh Granny
16
Just Fishing
15
 Happy Day
18
The Band
18
 Smoothie
15
Robert Speirs (A)
  
Having an Old Chat
15
 
What a Punch
15
 
Robert
15
Bob Kelly (B)
 Carol
11
 Joyce
15
One in Three Out
12
 Rough Crossing
12
Search for the Queen
14
 Barcelona Street Artists
12
Louise Greenhorn (I)
 Disappointment
15
 Emma Meant to be Catching Horses!
15
Frozen in Flight
18
 First Love
18
Indian Band Player
9
 Puppy Love
15
Paul Hunter (I)
  
 
Robin Saunders (B)
  
 
June Fotheringham (I)
  
   
         
         
Lesley Dignon  (B)
  
 
Steven Bell (B)
  
 
Liz Robertson (B)
  
 
Craig Townsend (I) Charlie
17
 Artist at Work
17
  Looking
20
 Daddy's Little Princess
14
Samantha
16
 The Driver
18
Derek Chambers (B)  
 
Rachel Levy (B)  
   
         
   
 


 

Yearly Standings 2009 - 2010

MEMBER
CAT
1
2
3
4
TOTAL*
Less
FINAL STANDING
 
 
PRI
PRO
PRI
PRO
PRI
PRO
PRI
PRO
PRI
PRO
PRI
PRO
PRI
 *
PRO
 *
Gordon Scott
A
 56 49
54
47
 50 47 49 47 209 190 43 41
166
  
149
  
Steve Collier
A
 14 31
32
         14 63 0 0
14
  
63
  
Ian McIntosh
A
 47 50
        47 50 0 0
47
  
50
  
George O'Toole
A
 45 47
51
51
         96 98 0 0
96
  
98
  
Fred Roe
I
    
               
 
 
Vera Roe
B
    
               
 
 
Willie Mills
A
 53 55
57
55
 54 53 50 52 214 215 47 51
167
 1st 
164
 1st 
Debra Mills
I
 19 31
20
16
   15     39 62 0 0
39
  
62
  
Ian Gidney
I
 43  
        43   0  
43
  
 
Stephen Williams
B
    
               
 
 
Stuart Robertson
A
 43 49
      46 43 95 0 0
43
  
95
  
Jim Reid
I
 50 47
51
47
 45 49 29 46 175 189 28 43
147
  
142
  
Dougie Cockburn
I
   42
35
49
 31     47 66 91 0 0
66
  
91
  
Mike Stone
B
    
               
 
 
Sarah Jane Keeley
I
    
               
 
 
Linda Richardson
I
49 43
53
46
         102 89 0 0
102
  
89
  
Hugh Griffin
A
 52 48
52
55
 46 48 47 43 197 194 43 43
154
  
151
  
Scott Boyd
B
    
               
 
 
Jim McKenna
I
 44  
        44   0  
44
  
 
Grant Collier
I
   50
55
           105   0
 
105
  
Graham Gilmore
A
   34
          34   0
 
34
  
Steven Dowds
I
    
               
 
 
Andy Bremner
B 
    
               
 
 
George Rosie 
B 
   45
57
57
 53 53 53 50 163 205 0 42
163
 1st 
163
 1st 
Sandy Ramsay
I
 44 49
52
47
 42 45     138 141 0 0
138
  
141
  
Tom Anthony
 B   54
55
38
 50 48 48 49 153 189 0 46
153
  
159
  
Ian McNeill
 B    
               
 
 
Robert Speirs
 A 15 47
52
   45   45 15 189 0 44
15
  
145
  
Bob Kelly
 B   45
50
47
 44 45 37 39 131 176 0 36
131
  
140
  
Louise Greenhorn
 I 44 47
52
56
 55 51 42 48 193 202 37 45
156
 1st 
157
 1st 
Paul Hunter
 I    
               
 
 
Robin Saunders
 B    
               
 
 
June Fotheringham
 B    
  47       47   0
 
47
  
Lesley Dignon
 B    
               
 
 
Steven Bell
 B    
               
 
 
Liz Robertson
 B    
               
 
 
Craig Townsend
 I 44  
57
47
 44 48 53 49 198 144 42 0
156
 1st 
144
  
Derek Chambers B       54           54   0
 
54
  
Rachel Levey
B
    
  29       29   0
 
29
  

A = Advanced, I = Intermediate, B = Beginner
CAT = Category, PRI = Prints, PRO = Projected Images,
TOTAL* = Total Scores to Date, Less = 3 Lowest Scores Subtracted, Final = Final Score
Please report any discrepancies to willie@mccc.org.uk

 

 

Interclub Competition - Midlothian Camera Club
Mid Calder v Midlothian CC November 11th 2009 Judge Mark Dunnigan LRPS CPAGB
MEMBER
PRINT
SCORE
PROJECTED
SCORE
Gordon Scott Heading South
20
 Frozen Loch
16
  Mist Rising over Eildons
16
  
  White Horse in Mono
18
    
Ian Gidney     Quick Break
14
George O'Tool Falcon's Eye
15
 Notre Dame at Night
14
   
 
Simples
14
Willie Mills Bad Hair Day
19
 Blue Damselfly Resting
19 
  Chrome at the Forth Bridge
17
 Green Malachite Butterfly *
20 
  Stob Dearg, Buchaille Etive
19
  
 
Debra Mills Serenity Falls
14
  
Stuart Robinson  
Watch Out Mice
 15
Jim Reid Dali Museum
15
  
Hugh Griffin St. Conan's Kirk
18 
Mull Race
14
Graham Gilmore     Aberdour Daffodils
17
Tom Anthony     Swan
15
 
TOTALS    Mid Calder Camera Club
Pri 171
 Westlothian Camera Club
Pri 149
 
Pro 158
  
Pro 156
   
Tot 329
  
Tot 305
* Image of the competition

 

 

Interclub Competition - Livingston Camera Club (Jan 10)
 
MEMBER COLOUR PRINT
SCORE
MONOCHROME
SCORE
SLIDES
SCORE
Gordon Scott Dreaming of a New Pair of Shoes
16
 Dark Mountain
16
 Frozen Loch 16
  Frosty Morning
17
        
  Pedal Power
18
        
             
Ian McIntosh         Three's A Crowd
15
             
George O'Toole Snow Storm Approaching
13
        
             
Grant Collier         Calanaish
15
             
Willie Mills Dawn Beckoning
18
 A Winter's Day, BEM
16
 Forest Floor Colours
13
   
    Forth Rail Bridge IR
14
          Green Malachite Butterfly Body Detail
18
             
Debra Mills Lady in Red
15
        
  Water Lily at Dusk
17
        
             
Jim Reid Early Evening Ullswater
14
        
       
 
  
 
Hugh Griffin Eilean Donan
13
  
 
  
 
  I'm Watching You
16
        
             
Graham Gilmore         Aberdour Daffodils
15
             
Linda Richardson  
Winter Trees 14    
             
Craig Townsend Loch an Eilean
15
        
             
George Rosie         Pebbles High Street
14
             
Sandy Ramsay Sango Bay
13
        
             
Robert Speirs  
Fast Running Water
14
    
             
GRAND TOTAL
 
 
Livingston
 354
Mid Calder
365

 

 

Interclub Competition - 9 Clubs (Newtongrange MM) (Feb 14)
 
MEMBER PRINT
SCORE
PROJECTED
SCORE
Gordon Scott Pedal Power
16
    
  Trio
18
    
         
George O'Toole  
Falkirk Wheel
15
         
Grant Collier     Calanaish
16
         
Willie Mills A Winter's Day, BEM
17
 Damselfly
16
   
 
Debra Mills Lady in Red
16
    
  Water Lily at Dusk
17
    
       
Louise Greenhorn  
Snowscape
15
      View From The Ben
16
         
TOTALS  
84 
  
78 
GRAND TOTALS    
Musselburgh   175
Haddington   169
Livingston   164
Mid Calder   162
Mid Lothian   161
Armadale   160
Gala   159
Biggar   157
Beeslack   153

 

Interclub Competition - West Lothian (APR 12)
 
MEMBER COLOUR PRINT
SCORE
MONOCHROME
SCORE
PROJECTED
SCORE
Gordon Scott Frosty Morning 
17
Trio
20
 Frozen Loch
17
   
 
 Rannoch Moor Morning
12
  
 
             
Ian McIntosh      
Threes a Crowd
17
             
Willie Mills Portrait Study
19
 Winters Day BEM
18
 Damselfly
19 
   
Clovelly
16 
  
 
   
 
 
  
 
   
 
  
 
  
 
             
Debra Mills  
 
  
16
 Afterglow
15 
             
Craig Townsend  
 
  
 
 Hope
14
             
Louise Greenhorn Frozen in Flight
18 
  
 
  
 
  Stormy Causeway
20
        
             
George Rosie Dynamic Earth
15 
 Base Player
17 
 Mull Race
15 
             
TOTAL  
89
  
83
  
82
GRAND TOTAL          
 
  Armadale
225
 Bathgate
NP
 Mid Calder
254
  Linlithgow
 NP
 Livingston
250 
  
 

 

 

 

The results for the year 2008 - 2009

2009 winners were -

Overall Submitted Images

Advanced 1st Place
Willie Mills for Prints, Gordon Scott for Projected Images.

Intermediate 1st Place
Hugh Griffin for Prints, and a 3 way tie for 1st place for Projected Images with
Stuart Robinson, Hugh Griffin, and Graham Gilmore.

Beginner 1st Place
Sandy Ramsay for Prints, and Scott Boyd for Projected Images

For the totals - click here,
and to download the actual scores for all the appraisals for the year, click here


Image of the Year Competition 2008 - 2009

Advanced Section
Willie Mills - Street Opera

Intermediate Section
Hugh Griffin - Yacht Race

Beginners Section
Scott Boyd - Duck in a Flap


We have also won the following Interclub Competitions this year -

Mid Calder Camera Club vs Midlothian Camera Club
Mid Calder Camera Club vs Livingston Camera Club
The West Lothian Competition
 

- WHAT A YEAR -

Well done Mid Calder CC!!!

 

Open Appraisal 1 Oct 15th by Dougie Allan

MEMBER
 PRINTED IMAGE TITLE
SCORE
 PROJECTED IMAGE TITLE
SCORE
Gordon Scott Only One Left
17
 Collision Course
16
  Red Rider
20
 Scott's View
18
  Smailholm Tower
19
 Young and Old
17
Steve Collier A Wet Day at the Allotment
16
 Primary Colours
17
  Skipton, Yorkshire
16
    
Ian McIntosh Eight Sombreros
17
 Geisha
16
  Forest Floor
17
 Geometry
19
      Moth Eaten
17
Ian Gidney        
George O'Toole Blond
16
 Drama
15
  Falkirk Wheel
16
 Making a splash
16
  Firework
17
 Wheel of Fortune
16
Steven Foster        
Fred Roe        
Vera Roe        
Willie Mills Bank of the River Fowey
18
 Black Hole at the Black Bull
16
  Rainy Race Day Colours
18
 Busted Chair
17
  Street Opera
19
 Garden Madness
16
Debra Mills Falls of Eden
19
 Glow from Within
18
  Hotel Heliconia
17
 HDR Evening Sky at Linlithgow
18
  Jack in the Bluebells
17
 Sunrise at Stonehenge
18
Stephen Williams        
Stuart Robertson     Busy as a...Hornet Fly
16
      Eye to Eye
18
      Raspberry Ripple
16
Jim Reid        
Dougie Cockburn Boating Pond
15
 Clouds over Cammo
16
  Deep in Thought
15
 Mirror in the Union 
19
  Rack n Ruin
15
 On the Trail of the Lonesome Pine
15
Mike Stone        
Sarah Jane Keeley Dollar Sunset
15
    
  Sunset in Linlithgow
15
    
  Sunset over the Forth
15
    
Linda Richardson        
Hugh Griffin Stained Glass
17
 Corn Head
17
  Undecided
16
 Deep in Prayer
16
  Yacht Race
16
 Oban Sunset
16
Scott Boyd A Rose by any other Name
14
    
  Crammond Harbour
16
    
  On the Buses
15
    
Jim McKenna        
Derek Chambers        
Grant Collier        
Graham Gilmore     Last Light at Blackness
17
      Permission to Land
18
      Refelections of Science
18
Paul Fothergill        
Steven Dowds        
Collin Allan        
Andy Bremner        
Colin Evans        
Paul Clayden        
George Rosie         
Tom Anthony        



Appraisal 2 Monochrome Nov 26th by Elspeth Fear

MEMBER PRINT
SCORE
PROJECTED
SCORE
Gordon Scott Early Morning, River Tweed
20
Final Fantasy
15
  Mist Rising over Eildon Hills
19
Fred
19
  Riga Station
16
Victory
16
Steve Collier        
Ian McIntosh        
Ian Gidney    
A Quick Break 
18
     
Rolling Along
13
     
Steamed Up 
12
George O'Toole        
Fred Roe        
Vera Roe        
Willie Mills Capturing the Moment (IR)
18
Cheddar Gorge Stream (IR) 
16
  Chrome at the Forth Bridge
20
Grafitti Polska 
14
  Moon Over Tintagel (IR)
18
Steps to the Path (IR) 
13
Debra Mills Pollen in the Morning Light
18
Canal View 
14
  Serenity Falls at Heligan Gardens
19
Chromed Buggy On the Trot
15
  Still Standing Strong & Proud
16
Garland 
16
Stephen Williams    
 
 
Stuart Robertson Gateshead Millenium Bridge
16
Now, how did I get in to this mess
17
  Hard Day at the Show
15
Oh baby baby its a sad life!
17
  Dunstanburgh Castle
14
Purple Dahlia
17
Jim Reid Ghost Town
16
Lady_Blue
17
  Jamie
17
Petrified_Forest
18
  Lunar Landscape, Mono Lake
15
St_Peters_from_the_Tiber
18
Dougie Cockburn        
Mike Stone        
Sarah Jane Keeley        
Linda Richardson        
Hugh Griffin Au Natural
15
Man at Work
19
  Saint Conan's Kirk
18
Loch Long
13
  Steam Power
17
Snowdrop
13
Scott Boyd    
linthgow cemetary 
18
     
morton hall 
17
Jim McKenna        
Derek Chambers        
Grant Collier    
Crofter
16
     
Driftwood
16
Graham Gilmore    
Inside Tantallon's crumbling walls
16
     
Ten strings and a Dirty Rose
17
     
The piper calls the tune
18
Paul Fothergill        
Steven Dowds    
Cindy
20
     
Devilish
17
     
Pitter-Patter
14
Collin Allan    
Good View Down the Glen 
20
     
The Brave Man 
17
     
The Rear View Mirror 
14
Andy Bremner        
Colin Evans        
Paul Clayden        
George Rosie         
Tom Anthony        
Sandy Ramsay Charly
13
Durness Community Garden 
12
  Out in front
12
Edinburgh Castle
12
  Sango Bay
12
Sunset on Burntisland 
14



Appraisal 3 (Open) Feb 18th by John Miller (Detailed Notes)

MEMBER PRINT
SCORE
PROJECTED
SCORE
Gordon Scott Autum Glow
15
 Autumn Boat
13
  Frosty Morning
19
 Frozen Loch
18
  Ice Sheet
15
 Winter Frost
17
Steve Collier Bleu a la Plage
17
  
 
  Hibiscus Flower
17
  
 
  Window in Nice
15
  
 
Ian McIntosh  
 
 Dinner Time
15
   
 
 Kirk
12
Ian Gidney  
 
  
 
George O'Toole A Wet Day at Concorde
16
 Notre Dame By Night
20
  Eiffel Tower by Night
14
 Palace of Versilles
16
  Snow looms at Glen Coe
15
 Paris
13
Fred Roe  
 
  
 
Vera Roe  
 
  
 
Willie Mills Stag at Stob Dearg
17
 Blue Poppy
19
  Stob Dearg
19
 Gentle Smile
18
  Sunrise at stonehenge
19
 Robin Redbreast
18
Debra Mills Building upon a Reflection
13
 Falkirk Wheel on Display
15
  Fern Unfurling
18
 Golden Curcuma in Bloom
17
  Four Door Thatched Cottage
14
 Rusty Bolt
17
Stephen Williams  
 
 
  
Stuart Robertson Crocosmia " Lucifer "
9
 Blast Off
17
  Sweet Pea (Study at F2.8)
11
 High Key Dahlia
15
  Wise Hooter
18
 Watch out Mice
19
Jim Reid Dali Museum in Figueres
20
 Focusing Rings
19
  House on the Cliff
15
 Hats
18
  St Peters from the Tiber
16
 Moonlight Festival
13
Dougie Cockburn  
 
 Blown Fuses
17
   
 
 Storm Brewing
14
   
 
 Wrong Turn
12
Mike Stone  
 
  
 
Sarah Jane Keeley  
 
  
 
Linda Richardson  
 
  
 
Hugh Griffin Anstruther Harbour
18
 Mull Race
16
  Autumn at Loch Lubhair
15
 Water Spray
19
  Falls of Dochart
18
 Young Man and his Dog
18
Scott Boyd  
 
 Forth Rail Bridge
11
   
 
 Ratho Barges
15
   
 
 Waterfall
19
Jim McKenna  
 
  
 
Derek Chambers  
 
  
 
Grant Collier  
 
 Drink and Drive
20
   
 
 Feet in the Sand
16
Graham Gilmore  
 
 Deadly Silent
13
   
 
 Lagonda
13
   
 
 On the Rails
17
Paul Fothergill  
 
  
 
Steven Dowds  
 
 Charlie
16
   
 
 Solo
14
Collin Allan  
 
  
 
Andy Bremner  
 
  
 
Colin Evans  
 
  
 
Paul Clayden  
 
  
 
George Rosie   
 
 Cold Rucksack
13
   
 
 Pentland View
10
   
 
 Tool Time
13
Tom Anthony  
 
  
 
Sandy Ramsay Ben Lomond
11
 Beautiful Smile
17
  Falkirk Wheel by Night
13
 Loch Lomondside
12
  Five  Geese a Laying
16
 Sunset on Burntisland
12

 

Appraisal 4 (Wildlife) Mar 18th by Mark Dunnigan

MEMBER PRINT
SCORE
PROJECTED
SCORE
Gordon Scott
Egretta Garzetta
18 Eagle 16
 
Highland Stag
16 Swans on Morton Resevoir 19
 
White Horse in Mono
18 Yellow Eye 17
Steve Collier Black Headed Gull in Winter Plumage 16    
  Hover Fly on a Yellow Flower 14    
  Poppies 15    
Ian McIntosh     Blue 16
      Chaff 19
      Red 19
Ian Gidney        
George O'Toole Budge Up 17 Home to Roost 15
  Falcons Eye 19 Mandarin 19
  Prairie dogs 16 Simples 19
Fred Roe        
Vera Roe        
Willie Mills Bad Hair Day 19 Blue Damselfly Resting 20
  Early Bird 19 Blue Tit taking a Break 16
  King's Profile 15 My Favourite Visitor 16
Debra Mills        
         
         
Stephen Williams        
Stuart Robertson Cock Robbin 15 Like My New Specs Guys ? 17
  Common Pheasant 16 Red Squirrel 18
  Kestrel 15 Wheel of Love 18
Jim Reid        
         
         
Dougie Cockburn    
Fenced In
18
     
Waiting For a Bit
18
     
Walk this Way
17
Mike Stone        
Sarah Jane Keeley        
Linda Richardson        
Hugh Griffin
Cheetah at Rest
16
Lanner Falcon
19
 
Peregrine Falcon
17
Morag
17
 
Wise Old Hoolet
18
Praying Mantis
16
Scott Boyd    
Buzzard in the Wild
15
     
Duck in a Flap
20
     
Heron
20
Jim McKenna        
Derek Chambers        
Grant Collier        
         
Graham Gilmore    
Busy Bee
15
     
Fledged Chaffinch
19
      Suppers Ready 17
Paul Fothergill        
Steven Dowds        
         
Collin Allan        
Andy Bremner        
Colin Evans        
Paul Clayden        
George Rosie     
Cedar the Owl
16
      Horse 15
     
Wakey Wakey
14
Tom Anthony     Island Squirrel 19
      Norwegian Visitor 18
     
Wet Feet
19
Sandy Ramsay
Poppy
14
Happy Landing
17
 
Sunset over Linlithgow Loch
17
Peacock at the Binns
15
 
Where's Supper
16
Snowdrops
14
Ian McNeill    
Step Onto That?
16
     
Tree Climbing Goat
18




Yearly Standings 2008 - 2009

MEMBER
CAT
1
2
3
4
TOTAL
Less
FINAL STANDING
 
 
PRI
PRO
PRI
PRO
PRI
PRO
PRI
PRO
PRI
PRO
PRI
PRO
PRI
 *
PRO
 *
Gordon Scott
A
56
51
55
50
49
48
 52 52 212 201 46 44 166   157 1st
Steve Collier
A
32
17 
    
49
 
   45 81 45 0 0 81   45  
Ian McIntosh
A
34
52
    
 
27
   54 51 133 0 0 51   133  
George O'Toole
A
49
47
    
45
49
 52 53 146 149 0 0 146   149  
Fred Roe
 
        
 
 
                    
Vera Roe
 
        
 
 
                    
Willie Mills
A
55
49
56
43
55
55
 53 52 219 199 50 43 169 1st 156  
Debra Mills
I
53
54
53
45
45
49
     151 148 0 0 151   148  
Ian Gidney
A
      
43
 
 
       43   0     43  
Stephen Williams
B
        
 
 
                    
Stuart Robertson
I
  
50
45
51
38
51
 46 53 129 205 0 48 129   157 1st
Jim Reid
I
    
48
53
51
50
     99 103 0 0 99   103  
Dougie Cockburn
I
45
50
    
 
43
   53 45 146 0 0 45   146  
Mike Stone
B
        
 
 
                    
Sarah Jane Keeley
I
45
      
 
 
     45   0   45      
Linda Richardson
 
       
 
 
                    
Hugh Griffin
I
49
49
50
45
51
53
 51 52 201 199 46 42 155 1st 157 1st
Scott Boyd
B
45
    
35
 
45
   55 45 135 0 0 45   135 1st
Jim McKenna
I
        
 
 
                    
Derek Chambers
 
        
 
 
                    
Grant Collier
B
      
32
 
36
       68   0     68  
Graham Gilmore
I
  
53
  
51
 
43
   51   198   41     157 1st
Paul Fothergill